Moon Magic Reviews

Moon Magic has an overall rating of 3.9 based on 517 reviews. Customer feedback on Moon Magic is mixed: Moon Magic reviewers highlight positive aspects like beautiful designs, high-quality materials, excellent customer service, fast shipping, which strongly appeal to jewelry enthusiasts, gift shoppers, individuals seeking unique pieces, fans of spiritual and meaningful jewelry. However, Moon Magic is often criticized for its higher price point, limited customization options, occasional sizing issues, longer delivery times for some items.

3.9/5.0

517 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

2

2 Stars

3

1 Star

1

All Moon Magic Reviews (517)
TiaWilson_57
May 23, 2026
"Refund took way too long"
For some reason, getting my refund took much longer than I expected. The whole process felt slow and a bit annoying, especially since I had to keep waiting without much clarity.
LoriGuida_89
May 17, 2026
"Order was pretty much spot on"
I ordered a ring from moonmagic.com and was a little nervous about the sizing and the stone color, since you never really know until it shows up. But everything was pretty much exactly what I picked. The order details looked right, nothing seemed to be missing, and the engraving was spelled correctly too. I’m happy with it, especially since I’ve had jewelry orders go wrong before.
Victoria_mazor92
May 05, 2026
"Glad I Didn’t Wait"
It arrived really fast and everything was smooth, no issues at all. i’m glad I went ahead and ordered it instead of risking delays or dealing with problems later.
hello_mai934
May 02, 2026
"Pretty easy site to shop on"
I tried moonmagic.com for the first time after seeing a few people mention it, and the site was easy to use. The menus were simple to follow, and I liked that I could filter the jewelry without clicking around forever.

The product photos loaded quickly for me, and the sizing/details were clear enough that I didn’t feel like I had to guess. Checkout was straightforward too, which I always appreciate because that’s usually where I start second-guessing a site.

The only thing I’d change is having fewer pop-ups on some pages, but it wasn’t a big deal. Overall it was smooth, and I’d probably use it again, especially if I keep seeing good feedback from other shoppers.
James_schnee00
April 23, 2026
"Surprisingly, the warranty came through"
I had a small issue with my ring and wasn’t expecting the warranty to be much help, but it actually covered it without a big hassle. Support got back to me quickly and walked me through what to do. I’m still a little skeptical about warranties in general, but this did make me feel better about buying from Moon Magic.
Douglas_smith70
April 14, 2026
"it feels really nice on for..."
it feels really nice on for daily wear. The only thing is the clasp can get a little annoying sometimes, but overall it’s still comfortable
richard1991
March 15, 2026
"They helped, but communication could be better"
I’m not trying to be harsh because the customer service wasn’t bad, but the communication definitely could’ve been better. I had to wait a few days to hear back and ended up asking twice about my order, which was a little frustrating. To be fair, they did help me in the end, it just wasn’t the quickest process
tomas-Myers
March 11, 2026
"Solid everyday ring"
I’ve been wearing this ring every day, and honestly, it feels really solid. It hasn’t picked up many scratches either, which surprised me a bit since I’m not exactly careful with it.
jamiepennhunt
March 10, 2026
"Extremely Disappointed – Quality and Service Issues"

I purchased two jewelry sets totaling over $600. Within 60 days, every piece had tarnished, with two becoming completely unwearable after only a few weeks of normal wear. Shipping was delayed, and weeks of emails to customer service went unanswered. After reading other reviews, it’s clear this is a recurring issue with rapid tarnishing, poor quality, and unresponsive support. I cannot recommend purchasing from this company.

KristineGrosbier
March 10, 2026
"Looks Nice, But I’m Still Annoyed"
I’ll give them this: it does look clean and nice. But it’s frustrating because whoever handled this clearly knew how to make it look good, so there’s no excuse if the rest of the experience doesn’t match...
rebecca_Smith70
February 22, 2026
"Finally Found the Ring in My Size"
I’d been looking at this ring for a while and expected my size to be sold out by the time I decided to order it. I’ve had that happen plenty of times before, so I wasn’t getting my hopes up. But when I checked, they actually still had my size in stock. It was such a nice little surprise, and I was able to grab the ring I really wanted without having to settle for something else.
Alina_roberts78
February 19, 2026
"Pretty stone, just lighter than I expected"
I got my ring from Moon Magic the stone looks real to me, not plasticky or fake at all. I’m kind of rushing, but wanted to say the color is really pretty, just a bit lighter than it looked in the online photos. I still like it and I’m happy with the ring, I just thought it would be a deeper shade.
violaanthony8875
January 22, 2026
"Looked really nice in person, but fit way..."
Looked really nice in person, but fit way smaller than I expected. Checked the size chart before ordering too, so was annoying
LoisBrown
January 04, 2026
"Cute packaging, honestly better than I expected"
My order from moonmagic.com showed up in really nice packaging. I wasn’t sure if it would actually feel as special as it looked online, but the box was cute and everything inside was protected well, with no damage at all. The little details while opening it were a nice touch too, not overdone, just enough to make it feel a bit more thoughtful. Overall, I’m happy with the presentation.
hello_herminia734
January 03, 2026
"Checkout was a bit of a hassle 😅"
The payment page was acting kinda weird and kept loading strangely, so I ended up having to enter my card info twice. My order did go through in the end, but the checkout definitely wasn’t as smooth as I hoped :/
judith_Shea76
December 21, 2025
"I got a bracelet from Moon Magic..."
I got a bracelet from Moon Magic for my sister’s birthday, and she was so happy with it :). Picking the size and style was simple, and it had that nice balance of feeling special without being too flashy.

It looked just like the photos when it arrived, and the packaging was really nice too. Definitely a good option if you need a thoughtful gift but don’t want to spend forever overthinking it.
RexSutton_84
December 17, 2025
"No surprise fees when it arrived"
I was kind of expecting some random extra charge at delivery, or maybe I just worry about that too much, but everything was clear up front. The customs and import fees weren’t a nasty surprise, which was a relief...
SLAMA
December 10, 2025
"Decent promo, but I expected more"
I used a promo code on moonmagic.com and it did work, so that part was fine. I was kind of hoping the discount would be bigger though. The jewelry is really pretty, and the site was easy enough to use, but even after the promo, the prices still felt a little high to me. I mean, it’s nice they have offers at all, I just wish they knocked a bit more off...

View More Reviews

Moon Magic Q&A

Has anyone else experience extreme low quality with their item? our $699 ring was bent with the weight of clothes and now warranty does not cover!

FrancesMartin
October 10, 2020

“Yes, the main stone in my ring fell out after four months and the company is refusing to refund me. It's only four months old. They say it's only got a one month warranty! A month?! They only have a month warranty because they expect them to break and don't want to give you your money back. Disgusting.”

How long will the plating last on a necklace? i want to buy my friend the gold plated aries necklace but i'd look for something else if it wares quick

redduck104
April 13, 2020

“Hello Abby, Our jewelry is made from a range of precious metals, including the following: 925 Sterling Silver, Solid Yellow, and Rose Gold and 14k Vermeil which is 925 Sterling Silver plated in 14k Rose and Yellow Gold (this coating is 50% thicker than traditional gold-plated pieces, keeping it beautiful for years to come). All the best, Moon Magic”

Can you share a success story using moon magic?

organicrabbit979
May 01, 2020

“Hello Dorothy, Thank you for your question. You can take a look at our reviews here or on our website and you will see many success stories from our happy customers. All the best, Moon Magic”

Is moon magic a scam or a legit company?

purplegoose276
September 27, 2019

“ITS 100% scam”

What made you choose moon magic over similar businesses?

JoannBell
December 05, 2019

“On their website they had really good reviews! I should have done a little more research!”

Have a question about Moon Magic?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.